Question Details

[solution] »

Please review the attached case and provide answers to the following questions. 

1/ What di


Answer Download

The Question

Please review the attached case and provide answers to the following questions. 

1/ What did the first company?s sales rep do correctly?

2/ What did the first company?s sales rep not do correctly during the actual sales call?

3/ What could the rep from the first company learn that would enhance his chances of receiving subsequent  orders?

4/ What did the gentleman from the 2nd company not do well and what are the potential implications of this? Consider Features, Advantages and Benefits when answering this question.

5/ What did the gentleman from the 2nd company do well to win me over as well as to create an Advantage for his company?

6/ The son who I talked prices with did exhibit selling skills as we went through the pricing. Explain in detail what he did as part of a selling process to help secure the order.

7/He also helped reassure me about my decision.  What was he likely preventing  in my thinking as I considered the deal we had made. Why would he have done this ?

8/ Explain in detail why I was prepared to work with the second company to be  sure they got the order despite their price being higher than his competition.

9/ What negotiating style did I use?  Explain why I used this style.

10/ Where was value created  by each company and detail what the value created?

A few years ago our roof started to leak on our home. We called in two wellknown roofing companies to help us understand what the situation was.


The rep from the first company looked at the leak in our living room and


said we needed a new roof. He said it was a 25 year old roof and that it was


typical of what was happening in our subdivision.


The sales rep estimated our roof size as we stood in the front yard and then


quoted me a price. He said he had done a lot of work in our neighbourhood


and then asked if I wished to have the job done offering no more




Once he learned from me that I was waiting for another company to look at


the leak, he said he would follow up in a few days to see if I wanted to have


his company do the work.


The second company arrived later that day. An older gentlemen in a work


truck arrived. I explained the problem we were having and that we had a


leak in our living room. He smiled, grabbed a ladder asking if he could


survey the tiles on the roof. With permission given, he quickly climbed onto


the roof. He walked around on the roof surveying its two levels. When he


came down he explained that the roofing shingles had reached the end of


their life expectancy and that the roof would need to be replaced very soon


as leaks were going to start to be a regular occurrence. He explained that


the shingles had lost their granular integrity and coating which happens


over many years which results in it starting to leak. He also said that there


was a bare spot above the front area of the house. He asked where the


living room was. I replied that it was at the front of the house. The location


of the leak and lack of tiles he had seen matched, resulting in the leak.


He offered to give us a temporary patch and with permission, he proceeded


to grab tools out of his truck along with a couple of shingles over his


shoulder, climbed his ladder onto the roof and started to hammer.


He came down a few minutes later smiling and said that the repair he did


would give us a few weeks on that spot but that further leaks were not going to be long in coming. He advised that based on his experience it


would no more than a month before other leaks would develop.


I thanked him and offered to pay for his service being relieved that the leak


was looked after. He politely declined saying that he was just happy to help




Being impressed by him as well as feeling a sense of obligation to him, I


asked what his company could offer over other competitor?s that had


started doing working in our area. The following conversation then took


place: ?Our employees are long term with our company ?he announced proudly.


?So, what does that mean to me?? I asked


He said ?Well, we know the quality of the work our guys do ?


I said? That doesn?t? necessarily mean it is good quality, just that they have


worked for you for many years?


He then said? Oh but we only keep the best, most reliable workers year


after year?.


?So that means ?.?? was my response.


He went on to say ?The employees that do a particular roof are responsible


for any shingles that come off the houses they work on for at least five




?So?? I asked.


His response was ?They must come and repair the roofs they have done if


there are any problems.?


? I see? I said. ?Why does that matter to me?? starting to see a pattern in


his sales process. ?They do good work, in part, because they don?t want to be returning to


homes on their time?


He assured me that quality work is their main objective.


I then asked him how long his company had been in business.


He said ? We have been in business since I started the company 40 years


ago and I am proud of this with the roofing business being full of companies


that come and go?


?But that is the nature of your business which makes me think of you as a


more stable company but provides no value for me really? I said.


?Well, I can see that point of view, but you know we will always be there if


you need us?.


?So I can count on you to be there if I need you??


?You got it? he said. Adding ?that the quality of their work in an industry


where there is a lot of turnover is why we keep the same high quality


workers year after year. We see them as a real asset?.


I asked him for a price being sold on him and his company.


He smiled and headed for his truck after giving me his son?s business card




?Give my son a call. He?ll be happy to talk about the quote with you. I am


out of touch on pricing but we are really busy and the feedback he gives me


tells me that we are competitive. I just assess the job and do small repairs.


He?ll have the roof dimensions later today so you can call him tomorrow for


a quote?


?But you didn?t measure for the estimate? I said


He chuckled and replied? I have been doing this work all my life so I can eye


ball dimensions just by being on the roof. I?m never wrong after all these


years. Besides we always bring an extra couple of bundles, just in case. ? I called his son later that day and sure enough, he did have the dimensions


as his father had said he would. I was quoted $3200.00 which was $400.00


more than the competitor?s price. I indicated his price was high to the


competition. He then asked who the competition was. I told him, at which


point he indicated that his company was usually high to this competitor I


had named but there was good reason for this. He went on to tell me that


his company?s business warranty was two years longer than this competitor.


He added that is a recent survey conducted by their trade magazine, his


company had been rated number one for customer satisfaction in the


Greater Toronto Area.


?Our quality of service as provided by our crews with them being long time


employees costs us a little more but is worth it based on our customer?s


satisfaction I hear about with letters from many of them, even years later.


They tell us over and over again that the quality of our work as well as the


professional attitude of our teams and the cleanliness of the site after we


are done, inspire them to write to us.


?I also sleep better at night knowing our customers are pleased.?


Hearing all of this, I was ready to so sign up. I then suggested that we


should find a way to make this work.


?I would like to have you do the work but $400 is close to 15% higher.?


I did add that the service his father had provided was an incentive for me.


He agreed and offered a price reduction of $200.00 and an extended the


full warranty another year on the installation saying that the business is


appreciated and he has no concerns about the quality of the work his


people will do.


?We stand behind our work, so I am able to offer another year? was his


closing statement.


I accepted his offer after a clarification of the details of the warranty. He


then set a date for the work to be done based on my availability and him having his team?s schedule in front of him. He thanked me for the business


assuring me that my satisfaction was his company?s greatest concern. He


promised that his father would follow up with me a week after the work


was completed to be sure that I was satisfied.


The crew that did the work was professional, thorough and cleaned up after


they had finished their work just as I had been promised.


In fact his father did drop by a few days after the work was completed just


to be sure that I was satisfied with all aspects of the job.


The sales rep from the competitor did follow up with me 10 days after the


business had been booked at which time I did tell him that he had lost the


order to a competitor. I could tell from his words and tone that he was not


pleased about not getting the order.


Solution details

Solution #00070207

[solution] »

Please review the attached case and provide answers to the following questions. 

1/ What

Uploaded by: Tutor

Answer rating:

This paper was answered on 14-Oct-2020

Pay using PayPal (No PayPal account Required) or your credit card . All your purchases are securely protected by .

About this Question






Oct 14, 2020





We have top-notch tutors who can do your essay/homework for you at a reasonable cost and then you can simply use that essay as a template to build your own arguments.

You can also use these solutions:

  • As a reference for in-depth understanding of the subject.
  • As a source of ideas / reasoning for your own research (if properly referenced)
  • For editing and paraphrasing (check your institution's definition of plagiarism and recommended paraphrase).
This we believe is a better way of understanding a problem and makes use of the efficiency of time of the student.


Order New Solution. Quick Turnaround

Click on the button below in order to Order for a New, Original and High-Quality Essay Solutions. New orders are original solutions and precise to your writing instruction requirements. Place a New Order using the button below.


Order Now